We did the private volcano tour for sunset. It was really incredible! Our driver, Scott, was amazing. He had really interesting commentary, as well as suggestions for places to eat, visit, and see. The sunset itself was absolutely gorgeous, but it was chilly at 10,000 ft at the summit, so bring a pair of pants and a coat if you plan on going!
The car ride was pretty windy so if you get carsick easily I wouldn’t recommend it. It’s good to do this early in your trip to Maui so that you can learn more about the island and fun places to go. That being said, I wouldn’t do too soon after your flight since it is a good 6 hours of mostly being in the car.
The dinner after the sunset was incredibly good. I had the Island Platter I believe but everything at the restaurant is very fresh.