Whatever tour you choose, it's the weather and the naturalist weaving a great story that will make or break your experience. Ours, on Discovery Tours, was great. They had two boats and I don't think it made any difference which one we were on. But with overcast skies, a low tide and a bit of wind, the trip was quite rough. But we did see whales and dolphins, and received a lot of information about these wonderful mammals. It's something you probably will only do once. And this is an excellent area to do it.