Pros: We got to see a lot of whales
Cons: 2 hour trip was 90 minutes, Boat was full of a lot of very drunk people
We went for Pacific Whale Tour out of Lahaina at 2 pm, and much to our surprise the boat was full of some very odd individuals; many of them pissed, and some looking like they were just pulled off the street. I'm not sure if this was just our trip, but the crew were really pushing the drinks for the full ride.
The 2 hour tour started with everyone standing in line so we could get photographed getting onto the boat. Needless to say that took 10 minutes and the boat didn't leave until 2:20. We got back early, so our trip was only 90 minutes.
The commentrary was pretty average in terms of content and interest, and there were a lot of lame jokes. The upside is that in February there are a lot of whales in Hawaii, so we did see a lot of whales, many of them breaching.
Tip: When you're waiting in the staging area to load the boat, wait on the right side of the staging area, as that is how they form the line for loading the Boat (from the right side of the Boat). That will give you a chance to get the best seats, which are in the front of the boat, on either the main or top deck