For my dad's birthday I booked a half-day trip with Captain Tim and had an amazing time! Capt Tim gave us a neat little boat ride/tour of the marina and key west, took us to the Boca Chica sandbar to get out in the water and play, and finally wrapped the trip up with some light tackle fishing. The first mate was so attentive while we were fishing and helped to make sure our bait was on and showed me how to cast and everything. Within moments of fishing I caught my first ever fish! My dad had a great time too and was very happy to catch a handful of fish. Overall Capt Tim and his first mate made it a very enjoyable experience for my dad and I. I know who I will boat with whenever I make back down to Key West!
On a side note, other things that I appreciated was the fact that his website was very easy to navigate and I was able to book my charter online. When I called to confirm the details a day before the trip Capt Tim was very polite and informative. I love a great customer service attitude and voice! He also pointed out other things to do in the area after our charter was over.