I posted this review on Yelp, but I found Toa here on TripAdvisor, so thought I'd post here as well:
I can't recommend this luau enough and I felt compelled to write this review. We were looking for an intimate and authentic luau experience, as so many out there feel like they just churn through tourists en masse. Toa is not that, and it was EXACTLY what we were looking for. They actually cap their show at 200 people to maintain that small-group feel.
The scenery is beautiful, nestled right in the Waimea Valley. The performance put on by the team was talented, high energy and heartfelt. It felt like everyone really cared and was having a blast.
It was a little far from our hotel (about 1.5 hours with traffic), but well worth the trip. There's a reason this luau has so many 5 star ratings, and we found out first hand. Make the trip, you won't regret it. Great job to everyone there!