BYOB actually ended up being so much better than not-byob (just a bar on a boat that you have to wait in line for each drink) since we could bring as much as we wanted of whatever we wanted. I made piña coladas, and Carley and I partied hard with the other fun passengers. The DJ kept the music going all night and we danced and drank and danced some more! Everything was fabulous and went smoothly except for the two frat-tastic idiots that yeeted themselves off the top deck of the boat, into the ocean, in the dark. Thankfully the captain, who was rightfully annoyed but not too worried, did a quick “man overboard” maneuver got us all back to partying in about 2 minutes. She was amazing! The whole crew was professional and accommodating and even offered to take as many pictures and videos as we all wanted. I would definitely book this experience again!!
Ps: I would NOT recommend jumping off the boat, because why would you want to ruin the evening for everyone else???