My husband and I recently booked a lesson with Sea Maui Surf and we loved it! We were celebrating our honeymoon in Maui and our instructor, JT, was really great! He was very positive, encouraging (I was quite nervous at first) and we had some laughs. We also saw a turtle while surfing which apparently is goodluck!
We would highly recommend him if you're in the area and interested in learning how to surf and catching some waves! Only regret we have is running out of time and not going back for another lesson with him.