lilly_white_tourist
Aug 2019
We did this tour with high hopes after already doing the sister ship (Clipper City)
The Shearwater is MUCH smaller. There are no seats. People could sit on storage boxes, pipes, or the ground. There is not much of a ledge around it either and if you're up the front you have to move to go with the sail being raised, manoeuvred or dropped. They don't give you cushions to sit on, bear in mind you're on this for 2 hours!
The wine is served in plastic cups (not wine versions....) . The girl serving it had done her homework and knew lots about the wines. The first wine was absolutely gorgeous - an Austrian wine, after that it was downhill. Two of our party would be avid wine drinkers and even they couldn't stomach 2 of the wines served. They weren't great at topping you up either, despite being told it was "drink as much as you like".
We didn't get much food as they had two average size platters for 40 people and unless you were next to it, you had a wobbly walk to get to it. The toilet was downstairs and accessed through a door down the back of the boat and down narrow dark stairs. The toilet was immaculate to be fair.
The views of course were spectacular, we had the best of weather which of course added volumes to it. But having one of our party that had a knee replacement, and being stuck on the floor, this really wasn't an ideal way to sail. When you see the accessibility of their sister ship - and the seating etc that it has, I really have to wonder why they put people on, essentially a posh booze cruise, on a vessel that really isn't suitable for the clientele it probably aims at. I'm just going to assume it's the over 30's range.
But I'd absolutely recommend going on the sister ship, which has a full bar, and plenty of seats!! This is not suitable for anyone who has had knee replacements or restricted movement as you cannot guarantee having somewhere to sit.
Response from Host
Sep 2020
I am sorry that your expectations were not met by your experience aboard the Shearwater schooner. She is a classic and nationally landmarked once-private yacht built in 1929. She is a Gatsby-era, museum-grade artifact of the Roaring '20s, the Gilded Age, or the Jazz Age, and has a very colorful history.
That is part of the charm of the boat and we can't change that or it will degrade its authenticity. We strive to communicate the different qualities of each of our vessels so that our guests can select which boat feels like a better fit for them. Shearwater, an all-wood vessel with masterful teak and mahogany deck and structures, at 82 feet (25m), is more old-time & reminiscent of a bygone era of American yachting, with a server walking around and providing beverages from a cooler rather than from a proper bar. The Clipper City, by contrast, at 158 feet (48m), is a replica of a clipper ship that sailed from 1854 to 1892, and is has a big ship feel to her.
I feel badly that your friend was uncomfortable; if informed of their condition, the crew certainly would have made accomodation to ensure an appropriate seating location; we would bring up a cushion for elderly or infirm guests.
For the wines, we our wine expert samples and selects different wines all the time; I am sorry that some of them were not winners. We select from organic and biodynamic small vineyards, so they are constantly changing and perhaps the next week's wines would have been more to your tastes.
Either vessel provides a unique experience and embody different historic aspects of sailing in America, and, of course, personal preference will dictate who chooses which vessel, and I would agree/argue that Shearwater represents a casual elegance for the adventurous and agree that it is more oriented towards a more active and able-bodied clientele.
Thank you for this opportunity to respond to your feedback.
-Tom