What an adventure! To sum it up:
Pros = highly skilled, enthusiastic, professional, safe, & friendly crew. 1st Cathedral is a world class dive site. Sea life was bustling.
Cons = tiny & uncomfortable boats. Lackluster lunch.
Awesome dive sites; we only did Wash Rock & 1st Cathedral and the latter was a spiritual experience. I can see why people would get married/proposed to there. We saw a friendly octopus, a giant moray eel chillin on the wall, and many others. Abby was great in her enthusiasm about the wildlife down there.
Unfortunately no 2nd Cathedral but I'm assuming that's because conditions were ROUGH that morning! Dive Maui's boats are tiny and it was a completely full boat, so not the most comfortable experience in waves that were literally whipping the boat up and down. Pretty sure everyone got seasick and 3 people fed the fishes... repeatedly. Definitely glad we were on our Bonine regimen. Can't control nature but the crew was AWESOME. Despite a full boat, they split the group up with 2 divemasters (I believe 6 guests per group) and staggered our entries such that the experience didn't feel too crowded. The waves on the surface were so rough that in the process of descending, I lost one of my integrated weight pouches, 4 lbs and all. I let Abby know once we were on the bottom and she was immediately on her way back to the boat to get me a replacement, then we were on our way making up for lost time. Didn't even feel like we missed out on the Cathedral despite my little hiccup! She handled it like a champ.
The snacks were bars and rice krispie treats from Costco and the lunches were simple grocery sandwiches from Boar's Head and they ran out of meat sandwiches by the time it was our turn on the handoff. Usually I wouldn't mind a good vegetarian sandwich but without eggplant, mushrooms, or avocado, the veggie sandwich left much to be desired.
We rented our gear with Dive Maui and they were pretty basic. Don't love the Aqualung rental BCDs because this is not the first time the integrated weight pocket fell out on a dive, but they're pretty standard wherever you go. I did like the Aqualung Storm fins through renting them here and ended up buying myself a pair for future travels.
All in all, if you don't mind struggling a bit for adventure and prioritize the vibes and safety Dive Maui's crew brings, then this is it! If you're looking for a more comfortable/luxury boat diving experience, I'd look somewhere else.