MichiganMelissa04
Jun 2024
We enjoyed this cruise. However, there were some things that could have been better. The amount of cheese given for 2 people should have been doubled, or at least 50% more. It was not much at all. We paid extra for the hummus, olives, and fruit; even with these, it was not a whole lot of food for the cost. The champagnes were fine. I did not like that we had to share a table. When I inquired in advance, I was told that our party of two would be at a private table. However, what that looked like was a large table with a clear glass divider and two others at the table. Not at all private, and actually somewhat awkward. If the glass had been frosted, there would have been some semblance of privacy... but it was clear. So you had to do the friendly and greet your neighbors. In our case, it was a nice mother/daughter pair like my daughter and me. But I had zero interest in chatting the night away with strangers - I am an introvert and that is exhausting. So no, the tables are not necessarily private. Also, while on the one hand I appreciated the camaraderie and familiarity with which the primary host and wine server chatted with the passengers, on the other hand, it was a bit much. I guess it is a fine line between too aloof and too chatty, so that is tough to navigate I am sure. The view of the Statue of Liberty was wonderful from the water, and views of the city were equally stunning. I would do this again, don't get me wrong, but I would have liked to have gone in with a better understanding. So there it is. Hopefully somebody finds this helpful.
Response from Host
Jun 2024
Melissa, thank you for booking a cruise with us and taking some time to leave a review. We are happy to hear that you would join us again and sorry that you were disappointed by the portion sizes and that the nature of the seating arrangements was not clear and detracted from your experience. We will certainly take all of your comments into consideration as we strive to improve our cruises for the future and as we select which important information to convey to our future guests so that they have the right expectations. We hope to have another chance to provide you with a better experience! - Classic Harbor Line