I'll be honest, at morning check in I thought I'd made a bad decision but I was definitely wrong, going with these guys was a great decision. Captain was great and the crew was awesome. We were one of the first boats to arrive at the crater after watching wales along the way there. VERY COOL! After the crater he took us to another spot and we were snorkeling with sea turtles. EVEN COOLER! I'd recommend them for sure. The other boat might look impressive but I think you'd get lost in the crowd. Oh yeah, have a few free mai tais after you're done snorkeling on the ride back.