Best tour was NY by night from the Hudson, followed by the walking photographic tour, the photographer was superb and talented. Macey's parade was excellent, but the Italian Restaurant, whilst good, was over priced for what you actually had and the windows were partially obscured. You would have needed to drink yourself silly to make it value for money. We were asked to be there half an hour before the appointed time and all were left out in the cold and not permitted entry until 8.00am.
All tour operators were very good, knowledgeable and very polite.
What can you say about NY, the City that never sleeps. There are no words to describe the experience. Be prepared to walk and walk. It is easy to get around when you get used to the street planning. And the views from the top of the rock and the Empire State are amazing.
NY is expensive, but where isn't now-a-days. Food, variety and quality excellent as the service. However be prepared to tip anything from 10 to 20, even when at the bar.
All in all an excellent experience, to be highly recommended.